03/22/1850: Margaret Hughes vs. Phinehas Skinner & Ely Shepherd & Benjamin F. Baker (Willis)

Entry/Object ID

CC.0121

Collection

1839-1869 Platte County, Missouri, Circuit Court Docket

Archive Items Details

Description

"We the Jury find for the Plaintiff against Phinehas Skinner and Ely Shepherd and assess the Plaintiff's damages to the sum of $850.00 and we find the Defendant Baker not guilty." Missouri Supreme Court Opinion affirming judgment 13 Mo. 440 (1850): This was an action on the case by Mrs. Hughes against Skinner, Shepherd and Baker for an injury to her slave that occasioned his death, and was tried at the March term 1850 of the Platte Circuit Court. Upon the trial, it appeared that the plaintiff was the owner of a slave, Willis, worth $900.00 and the defendants, Shepherd and Skinner, were the owners of a store in which they sold intoxicating liquors not less than a quart, and a mill, and Baker was their clerk, In January 1849 the boy came to the mill with grain to be ground and while there went to the store with a bottle, bought a quart of whisky, carried it to the mill and there got drunk, started home about sundown and was found early next morning lying on his face in the road not far from the mill speechless, his jaws locked and frozen nearly to death. He was taken to the mill immediately, received immediate medical attendance, lived 8 or 9 days and died. The whisky was sold to the boy without any permit from his owner, and neither Skinner nor Shepherd were present at the time. The clerk (Baker) was in the habit of selling whisky to the slaves without the permission of the owners and Shepherd was frequently present when this was done and made no objection.” The jury found a verdict for $900, for which the plaintiff had judgment, after motions for new trial and in arrest were overruled.

Date(s) of Creation

3/22/1850

Other Names and Numbers

Other Names

Name Type

Enslaved

Other Name

Willis

Name Type

Enslaver

Other Name

Hughes, Margaret

Other Numbers

Number Type

Source Citation

Other Number

Circuit Court Docket Vol. D 1848-1852: Cir.D297-298

Copyright

Copyright Details

© 2026 BAAC All Rights Reserved

Research Notes

Research Type

Researcher

Person

Bill Nichols

Date

6/5/2025

Research Type

Researcher

Person

Robin Nava

Date

7/5/2025

General Notes

Note

1850.03.22 Cir.D.297-298 Hughes vs Skinner.jpg 1850.07.01 Skinner v. Hughes 1850 fB087F10.pdf 1850.07.01 Skinner v. Hughes, 13 Mo. 440 (1850).pdf

Note

BAAC workbook: 1839-1869 Circuit Court Docket CatalogIt version.xlsx [Circuit MJRHD 02.14.26]

Create Date

September 2, 2026

Update Date

September 16, 2026

Name/Title

03/22/1850: Margaret Hughes vs. Phinehas Skinner & Ely Shepherd & Benjamin F. Baker (Willis)