Name/Title
William Barnet McConnell [1849-1931]Entry/Object ID
2018.1.179Description
William Barnet McConnell [1849-1931] - husband of (1) Sarah Bonar Buchanan and (2) Emma McPherson Vandercook, son of George W. McConnell and Eliza Bonar.
Handwritten inscription on original album page read, "Will McConnell."
ACQUISITION NOTE: This photograph was purchased via eBay auction in 2024, by David O'Donoghue, who subsequently donated it to Candice Lynn Buchanan, in order to reunite the related images. From the same eBay vendor, Candice had purchased a later image of William (item # CAND-AN007-0032) as well as an image of his first wife, Sarah Bonar "Sadie" (Buchanan) McConnell (item # CAND-AN007-0031). Per correspondence with the eBay vendor, Candice learned that the images were obtained at a large estate sale in Illinois. Several antique albums yielded at least 100 images. The vendor photographed the album pages before removing each image from the album to be sold separately on eBay. Though the images were identified in the album with handwritten inscriptions, the eBay listings did not include those captions. Candice discovered the images while searching eBay for items associated with Waynesburg, Pennsylvania. Due to many years of associated research, she recognized Sadie immediately. To help ensure accuracy and prevent bias, Greene Connections volunteer Glenn Toothman also compared the eBay item with Sadie's Waynesburg College, Class of 1868 graduation picture (item # WAYN_AN001_1868_0001). To determine if any additional or related images might be available, Candice looked at the vendor's entire listings and quickly discovered the image of Sadie's husband (item # CAND-AN007-0032), identifiable by comparison to a later picture of him published in The Record: Historical, Personal and Other Sketches, Politics, Literature and Education, Social and Fraternal Affairs, Illustrated (Fargo, N.D.: Clement A. Lounsberry, 1895–1905), photograph of William McConnell [WorldCat: https://search.worldcat.org/en/title/12388412]. Though neither image was captioned on eBay, further evidence to support the identifications lay in the fact that the vendor had posted these two CDVs with Waynesburg, Pennsylvania, photographer stamps, in combination with 20 images from Angola, Indiana. William had taken Sadie to live with his family in Angola, Indiana, after their marriage in Waynesburg on 9 September 1869. At this point, Candice contacted the eBay vendor to request any known provenance or ties to additional images. The vendor supplied the details stated here, in combination with images of the album pages bearing the original inscriptions that confirmed the identities of Sadie and William. A younger photo of William that had appeared beside Sadie in the album had already been sold and was thought to be lost, until David saw the images Candice had posted to Greene Connections and reached out to say that he had acquired the younger photo, which is the one you see here [item # CAND-AN007-0033] and generously offered to send it to Candice. The vendor reviewed the entries for additional family members and found a cabinet card identified as William's second wife, Emma (Vandercook) McConnell, which Candice could still acquire. Based on the evidence at hand, it seems most likely that these McConnell images (4 in total, 1 of Sadie, 2 of William, and 1 of Emma) were in a collection that belonged to friends or relatives of the McConnells in Angola, Indiana. Though it would have been ideal to acquire the collection intact with original order and context, we are extremely grateful to the vendor who promptly did all they could to help us document and identify these precious images. And, of course, a grand thank you to David for helping us to bring the young images of William and Sadie back together.
Original, professional photograph from S. G. Rogers, Photographer, Waynesburg, Greene Co., Pa.Photograph Details
Type of Photograph
Carte de VisiteCollection
Candice Lynn Buchanan CollectionMade/Created
Studio
Rogers, S. G. (Studio)Date made
circa 1865 - circa 1875Place
Location
Pennsylvania / Greene County / WaynesburgLexicon
Search Terms
McConnell familyOther Names and Numbers
Other Number
CAND-AN007-0033Relationships
Related Person or Organization
Person or Organization
McConnell, William Barnet [1849-1931]Provenance
Provenance Detail
Miscellaneous Series - Candice Lynn Buchanan CollectionAcquisition Method
DigitalNotes
This photograph was purchased via eBay auction in 2024, by David O'Donoghue, who subsequently donated it to Candice Lynn Buchanan, in order to reunite the related images. From the same eBay vendor, Candice had purchased a later image of William (item # CAND-AN007-0032) as well as an image of his first wife, Sarah Bonar "Sadie" (Buchanan) McConnell (item # CAND-AN007-0031). The photograph was shared with the Greene Connections: Greene County, Pennsylvania Archives Project in 2024. See ACQUISION NOTE above for full details related to identification.
SOURCE CITATION: William Barnet McConnell [1849-1931]; circa 1865-1875, image by S. G. Rogers, Photographer, Waynesburg, Greene Co., Pa.; item no. CAND-AN007-0033, Candice Lynn Buchanan Collection, Greene Connections Archives Project (GreeneConnections.com).